Can any group have the right to arm twist the government?

Consternation, bewilderment ...are the words one would reserve for experience while at some circus but the way responsible people are behaving is nothing short of a spectacle. A circus so badly managed that they end up embarrassing each other but still wait for applause from the audience. Indian democracy at its worst. Wonderful is it not?

First some facts: Corruption is a serious issue (instances are mindboggling, so is the low level of prosecution), Black money is a reality, billions are stashed abroad and much more must be within the country. There is no point in questioning the exact number, it is substantial and that cannot be denied. What is also true is that laws have been ineffective.

Despite all these hard facts subsequent governments have done precious little (one must add RTI has been a great step, i read Whislteblower bill is on the way). It seems corruption is not a concern, rightly so since it almost always favours the powerful. Corruption hits common people quite badly. So it is expected that there be a response and galvanise government into action. However unrepresentative ‘civil society’ may be and members wanting as also they may not have any ‘constitutional authority’ but people like Anna Hazare (and Baba Ramdev-whatever lacuna he has) do have substantial backing of people, and yes majority of people who may not come out to protest do want something significant to be done about corruption. The results of elections in Tamil Nadu is one of the ways people respond, but to carry this on without taking any action or systemic changes against corruption is akin to cheating people. Experience tells us same people do come back. Democracy is not solely about electing one’s representative, it is about being responsible representatives. The system doesn’t seem to be working that way, it has got reduced to winning and losing election, the interim that is referred to as governance is getting reduced to making money and influence. The growing nexus between corporate-government-market media is a source of serious concern.

The so called ‘civil society’ however well intentioned has absolutely no right to arm twist the government. They can at the best be pressure groups. And they have done a remarkable job of pressurising the government into framing the Lokpal, that was kept pending for so many years. It is now the discretion of the elected government to take what input it find necessary and present it to the parliament. During this process ‘civil society’ can express its displeasure, if any, by going for protest or hunger strike (which is the most peaceful and effective way of protest). All conducted within the law of the land.

It is unfortunate and regrettable the way Union Government has conducted itself in the past few months. It seems to be reduced to bunch of fixers, who are seen conniving. What is the problem here? Is handling Anna Hazare or Baba Ramdev or the issue they raise that challenging? Frankly is there any need for challenging or posturing? Why can’t they be frank and truthful? Why do they get reduced to placating and then calling names? Is this how the Party that people of the country of billion elected behave? I think too many manipulative people have got into the leadership position. They don’t see solutions they see opportunism. I am shocked

I must point to one person named Digvijay Singh, is this what Congress party all about? The man even went to the extent of kicking the shoe wielding ‘journalist’, even after the fellow was apprehended. He later mentions that he is foot soldier and has fought in the street. Yes truly Gandhian, so who is the goon who is the thug? (not that Baba Ramdev has done any better, but i am more inclined to the issues).

And yes i would like to see the promise made by the government on mother tongue texts and curriculum particularly for MBBS, activated at the earliest. The shortage of doctors in villages is shocking to say the least. Why haven’t they realised this six decades back or is it that like some buffoons who think ‘English is merit’ they allowed millions of people to suffer and die due to lack of medical care. Indeed India’s record on these matters is abysmal. If only mother tongue medium medical colleges were functioning things wouldn’t have been this bad. Look at the shocking statistics of MMR, U5MR, malnutrition...condition of PHCs. Are Rozgar yojanas meant only to make roads? And why public health centres less important than roads?

The Great Indian Bustard is now Critically Endangered

Excerpt from IUCN release...

One of the world’s largest species of bird is on the brink of extinction according to the 2011 IUCN Red List of Threatened Species for birds, just released by BirdLife International, an IUCN Red List partner.

The Great Indian Bustard (Ardeotis nigriceps) has been uplisted to Critically Endangered, the highest level of threat. Hunting, disturbance, habitat loss and fragmentation have all conspired to reduce this magnificent species to perhaps as few as 250 individuals.

Standing a metre in height and weighing in at nearly 15 kg, the Great Indian Bustard was once widespread across the grasslands of India and Pakistan but is now restricted to small and isolated fragments of remaining habitat.

“In an ever more crowded world, species that need lots of space, such as the Great Indian Bustard, are losing out. However, we are the ones who lose in the long run, as the services that nature provides us start to disappear,” said Dr Leon Bennun, BirdLife’s Director of Science and Policy.

This year’s update brings the total number of threatened bird species to 1,253, an alarming 13% of the world total.

“In the space of a year another 13 bird species have moved into the threatened categories”, said Jean-Christophe Vié, Deputy Director, IUCN Global Species Programme. “This is a disturbing trend; however the figure would be much worse if conservation initiatives were not in place. The information collected by the BirdLife partnership is crucial in helping us to continue improving conservation efforts. This is now more important than ever as the biodiversity crisis is already affecting our wellbeing and will continue to do so unless we do more to stop it.”

“Birds provide a window on the rest of nature. They are very useful indicators of ecosystem health: if they are faring badly, then so is wildlife more generally,” said Dr Stuart Butchart, BirdLife’s Global Research and Indicators Coordinator. “The changes we have documented in this year’s update will feed into the Red List Index for birds, a measure of trends in the state of the planet used by the world governments, global businesses and the United Nations, among others”.

condolence...

cartoon time!!

By the way for the Government that sends...

four cabinet minister (and also the cabinet secretary, in case one missed) to receive Baba Ramdev (though this blogger support the cause i find it shocking the business of receiving at the airport) there is someone called Irom Sharmila who has been fasting for more than 10 years now what has the government done. Or is that it is concerned with what is shown in TV or what happens in Delhi. Why is the government seen not proactive on serious issues? These are something that has been on the table for many years now, it is a shame that a democratically elected government (or is it a farce) finds itself in such a situation that it is reduced to placating. Though i would agree that Baba Ramdev is much more than what is manufactured for TV, of course there is also a serious concern on communal angle to the agitation. However to say that saffron represent communal is something i always find quite unpalatable. It is a manufacture of ‘intelligentsia’ around the power circles, who to cover up their lack of understanding look for easy references. Saffron might have been hijacked by communal elements for narrow reason doesn’t give anyone any right to equate saffron attire with communal, i object to it quite strongly. When people go old atleast in places like Kerala, i have seen they get religious and so choose saffron, also i recall when there is a vow to be taken before going to religious places (like say sabrimala) people wear saffron/black cloths. Even this blogger used to, and so did many whom i knew. That didn’t make them communal. Saffron has much deeper and valued meaning than what it is being reduced by competing forces. Common people’s reference to saffron is not what is sought to be seen by intellectuals, it is an agenda based reference that seeks to alienate. I am not for a moment undermining the threat of communal forces or the narrow worldviews. But there is a consistent effort by the western oriented media -mostly run by people who generally have no connection with reality except maybe the market, to alienate and to instigate. It serves their purpose quite perfectly, a divisive agenda or a society wherein there is constant tension between communities is where these people thrive, tragedy brings more audience. Also it helps in their discussion –which has become a raison de entre for many who are articulate with their tongue, they have their cause to shout in controlled space (i don’t know if there weren’t any slum children what would likes of crude women do!), there are regulars for each cause. With market working the perks are higher, and as it looks the government too is tuned into TV channels.

The other day i was watching this program by Karan Thapar (though i don’t prefer these people he for one does it well. Probably the best in the business), it was a scene wherein the Delhi elites were seen closing ranks against common enemy. Each one of the participant came with their own personal halo- quite common these days, and were found taking high (and higher) moral grounds, a man who was with HT (i recall BG Varghese from my Narmada days, he is quite respected figure though i did differ him those days) said with a rather heavy heart “How many Ramdev does it take to become a Gandhi?”. Well said, and yes “How many journalists does it take to become the editor of HT!!” Well i have the answer “none!!”...with plagiarism and Radias HT editors are hot property...just goes to show from this simple example that even senior journalists are on payroll, same could be true for TV channels. Coming back to Karan Thapar, though the discussion was quite nuanced, as is the case when editors, ex editors and intellectuals meet, the fact remains they too work in their ‘ridiculous’ (a word and its synonyms were frequently used in the discussion) framework. Though the panel seem quite concerned by the thought of “where the money is coming for Ramdev, what is his source” rightly so and yes please try to find out. But i can tell with certainty where Mister Thapar (and his esteemed guests) is getting his money from. Right in the middle of the discussions they went for ‘break’, and it is informed with much care that the program was sponsored by “community matrimonial”- a primitive conception “trying to capitalise market opportunity”. So clearly Thapar and his urbane intelligentsia coterie create their nuanced worldview and quaint exchange sponsored by trash!!. I was reading April Bernard (and posted her poem in my other blog) there is this line “not enough left in my mouth to spit”. I would suggest these people that instead of discussing how about spitting each other. If it is metaphorically appropriate why don’t take it literally.

This for all TV channels: everything works in context, clearly the Channels cannot expect to earn from regressive/dubious source and still claim to be on high moral grounds. Evidently they have failed quite miserably in their judgment. The fact that they are promoting dubious products/ archaic mindset on the one hand and broad mind talks on the other is what is referred to as hypocrisy. They could have refused they didn’t and that is what is called corruption. Any doubts? It is grievous because they were expected to be discerning, since they are holding huge responsibility. Ethical bankruptcy is accentuated by the fact that unlike common people they do have choices. They exercised their choice and favoured easy money. Must say Karan Thapar does speak well, it’s a pity though.

Shocking The other day i found the mall nearby selling ‘European cucumber’, i have never seen this cucumber before. I wonder how suddenly it has made its appearance in Bangalore (if it is in Bangalore i can safely assume it must be there across the country). So i am thinking then i see these cucumbers being dumped into garbage in tonnes all across Europe because of deadly strain Ecoli infection that killed many people. So i am thinking if it is dumped in Europe how is the same thing being sold here. Then i am thinking some Indian entrepreneur had this bright idea (wonder why Koreans don’t think this way) “kyonji why dumpji when you can sell, here we sell sand as cement. So why dumpji” ( i am told he even calls his wife dumpy!). So the mall decided to display it prominently being ‘customer friendly’. But then i am thinking if this is a health risk shouldn’t the public be atleast be aware of it. “Sirji tussi bhi na too much ho”.

The real deal

This blogger has been following Baba Ramdev for some time now, and though would differ on some of his views- views that tend to subjugate personal choices. But i do perfectly understand where these come from and know very well these are also rooted in the psyche of people that needs education and time to change, particularly when it comes to contentious issues like say homosexuality (Osho’s view on these matters is much nuanced and thought provoking). Nevertheless it need be pointed out that there has always been space for sections in Indian society be at informal level-what is being classified as hypocrisy by small timers is actually a way of tolerance. Unlike other more organised societies where these sections (and many more) where severely dealt, there was nothing to crusade for. For a rather ‘backward’ society where people live in tremendous disparities there are problems no doubt. Sometimes these responses could be backlash of market driven change that is sought through vulgarism and a vicious form of self aggrandisement. But this blogger will say with much certainty that unlike market sponsored activists (as also so called intelligentsia, who stampede news channel) Baba Ramdev is no hypocrite. And yes even if he has political ambitions this blogger has no problem, that is his choice and we should learn to respect however unpalatable it maybe it is for city based sophisticates. One fellow in English News channel (wonder why there are so very less number of English news channel...what kind of corruption is that?!) who also happens to be an editor of English magazine had the audacity to advice Baba Ramdev to stick to his yoga. Amazingly Talibanish one must say, i don’t know if anyone has ever suggested that a fellow who was once editing soft porn should even be taken seriously! Learn to respect diversity even though it may not go with your scotch or all your pretentious borrowed sophistication. Time for self appointed moral guardians to do some introspection.

This blogger also doesn’t agree that Baba Ramdev shouldn’t run or not run business, it his choice as long as things are legal. No one has any right to tell what other should or shouldn’t do. There has also been accusation of him being associated with far right (read RSS). This is another ploy to scuttle the issue. Taking the issue head on let me point out that RSS is a legal organisation and if the power that be thinks that this is a problem then ban it. Further the cumulative nature of Hindu society is such that it rarely favours extreme views or actions, unless of course there is sufficient provocation and manipulations by vested interests. This blogger would like to focus on effective law and order machinery rather than the perception created by vested interests (market media included). Indeed this blogger thinks that this whole drama of secularism has provided an easy exit for the most corrupt. For Crude woman & Co (just taking an example that has high symbolism value) this has been a space for promoting themselves, about nepotism, of course market does provide the modernism angle, the reason why you will find them stampeding in market sponsored moral high grounds. The same reason you will not find them in Baba Ramdev rally, there is a market driven class snob here that see references of common people as wanting. The reason why English news media will smirk, while millions of people in this country will rally behind Baba Ramdev. It is also shocking that Opposition political parties are lacking any articulation when the common people want them the most, the reason why likes of Baba Ramdev and Anna Hazare become viable option for people.

Baring some contentious points (mentioned earlier) this blogger strongly thinks that Baba Ramdev is raising some very relevant and serious issues, though there might be bit rustiness in the way these are articulated but this blogger believes that through the platform of fighting corruption/black money Baba Ramdev is also attempting to raise the self esteem of common people, whether through the issue of language or other culture pointers (that has been seriously undermined by market, there shouldn’t be any doubt that market works in cruder framework). His secularism doesn’t come through tutored English media; his understandings are something shared by common people that has been the foundation of Indian society in general. There are of course problems but Baba Ramdev is a genuine attempt on systemic change, this blogger wishes him all the luck.

Kerala’s tryst with June 1st

May 31st Place Kerala: sultry lazy day, time to walk the street or stretch on the beach,
June 1st Place Kerala: chaos of the colossal magnitude!!

Now you might wonder what happened in 24hours. It is a miracle that the monsoon keeps its date with Kerala almost always with clockwork precision. O how i miss the days on the beach watching the approaching rain (Alexander Frater’s Chasing the Monsoon has wonderful description of the festive occasion) it is an experience very difficult to express, and i would invariably end up on the beach on a rainy day. It used to be one of my must things to do those days. Quite funnily the onset of monsoon coincides with opening of schools. It’s unbelievable, the chaos with frantic parents, crying children in hopelessly crumpled new cloths, screeching autos, overcrowded buses...as if an animal spirit has entered the lethargy and Kerala in its unaccustomed frenzy ends up stampeding itself, it is on a standstill, clogged in traffic jams just about the time when action had begun. You just couldn’t help feeling sorry for the kids (indeed Jayshree Mishra’s Ancient Promise brings out this one). So enter the children into hallowed place of learning. Could have been pleasant! But then you wouldn’t experience the June 1st chaos of Kerala.