Fiction cannot tackle reality

Meanwhile, i read, there are rising number of cases of stigmatizing and ostracizing taking place. Fear of the dreaded virus is legitimate but the methods adopted in reaction by people wielding societal influence smacks of deep rooted depraved value system. Many doctors, nurses (even air hostesses) are being asked to vacate by despicable house owners and rent seekers. Imagine that these are the people who are putting their life on line to serve. Instead of providing moral support (that the PM so admirably initiated) some are being called "dirty". That is how they treat crucial and essential occupations. Dirty. Don't think these are coincidences. These are legacies from sanctum very much nurtured by purity seeking squatters and the ecosystem that thrived through castetva forces severely degrading this society. Corona is only a precursor to some serious cataclysmic challenges that the society is set to face as climate breakdown related changes gain momentum. This society is not really conceived to deal with these challenges. It lacks basic humanistic foundation of compassion and decency. One respite is that their influence is relatively less in the world than monster mullah's degradation that is spreading at an alarming rate and gun trotting life denying horrendous white racist Christians of US who wield immense power over the world.

Its amply clear that fiction minded (read religious) are constant threat to reality. These regressive values work to deny most of the crucial problems humanity face. When it is god's wish how can you take responsibility?! These segregation thriving fantastical fictions are going to be serious threat to communitarian response and humanitarian concerns. Further, these fiction minded who stick to the frame that deny reality in the garb of faith cannot be part of path breaking solutions (at the most they can be minor accretional contributors with all humbleness that religion inspires and denies). Innovative mindset needs a searing contact with reality and an openness to question and logically construct. Religions actively deny it, and is indeed a virus of mind that seeks to destroy humanness. Religions are freeloading on humanity, and its quite clear that its a dead weight nurtured and authenticated by some extremely devious section at the expense of all that defines humanity.       

We must thank unfortunate Italians for warning

These are the worst of the times and best of the times (apologies to Dickens). The virus is making a relentless march. Cities after cities are in lockdown. It is sad but the silence is overwhelmingly satisfying. Considering that India is overpopulated and psychopathically noisy this is such a respite not only for people who value silence but for other species too. It is as if earth has started to breathe again and a pernicious virus in its system is checked. Irony.

Sometime back a very interesting book was on the rack: Bullshit Jobs: A theory (by anthropologist David Graeber), he argues that there are millions of people across the world — clerical workers, administrators, consultants, telemarketers, corporate lawyers, service personnel, and many others — who are toiling away in meaningless, unnecessary jobs, and they know it. Bullshit jobs are jobs which even the person doing the job can’t really justify the existence of, but they have to pretend that there’s some reason for it to exist. There is a difference between bullshit jobs and shit jobs they’re not the same thing. Graeber elaborates “Bad jobs are bad because they’re hard or they have terrible conditions or the pay sucks, but often these jobs are very useful. In fact, in our society, often the more useful the work is, the less they pay you. Whereas bullshit jobs are often highly respected and pay well but are completely pointless, and the people doing them know this”. This is another irony and in a primitive society like India bullshit has always been prioritize over essential. It begins from the deviance of the sanctum. The only parameter of blessing is money and power. So we have scenes of youngster leaving essential jobs to join administration –the one that is elevated as epitome of intelligence among the unthinking populace and carries the perks and power assimilating all the feudal trappings. Few weeks back I was with these retired administrators in some interview panel (probably one of the least sick jobs) and asking question to the candidate as to “opportunities for india in corona spread” words like “supply chain disruption” “advantage over china” were liberally used for intense satisfaction of retired bureaucrats posturing as intelligentsia (they do have body language and compelling semantics though, clearly being in BS jobs with lots of power have taught them tricks of con artists. I too keenly learn this!). And this was in delhi, and I carried my sanitizer and was quite sure that the virus was in the next turn. When you are aware of what is happening around the world and take news in its seriousness, and not as an entertainment, then you will be concerned. You may even panic considering amazing level of ignorance and nonchalance of people around. You cannot blame the people they don’t take warning seriously because they are not aware. They are not aware because this society values bullshit. Literacy rarely becomes education hence they are easy fodder for manipulators. News is about entertainment and touches lowest commonest denominator at every available opportunity. With no moral ethical context conscience is rarely an issue. They normalize third rate movies and stupid game of cricket as news, they nurture manipulative mediocre actors and cricketers as influencers. A microorganism is here to sieve the bull shit. Primitive societies are in for a soul searching moment of meaninglessness.  

Thankfully India has the lessons of unfortunate countries like Italy and Iran. If we didn't have these warnings marketers would have scuttled all efforts for profit and hundreds thousands of people would have died by now. It is the same motivation that influence the biggest con artist of all time: Donald Trump. He is a breathing slimy feed appropriating everything for market to nourish. He epitomizes its crassness to dangerous insulating bullshit grandeur. He represents the degradation of the world we live. He is a constant reminder of what will happen to humanity.

As India is in lockdown PM Modi has taken some rightful actions and shown to be a compelling motivator in these bleak times, and to the chagrin of castetva forces posturing liberal saviors who seek to band him with rightist nutcases across the world with the help of fattened western fluffs, he is a seasoned and matured astute politician who knows how to work the deal with much restrain. He has been consistent when it comes to focusing on emerging challenges such as renewable source of energy, climate change matters so on. It is however necessary that neoliberal context needs to rethink on basic income to the unorganized sector. 

A society that doesn’t have much sense to distinguish right from wrong nor any parameter to decide these in such instance righteous authoritarian interventions works well. Mr. Modi intervened at the right time to drill the seriousness of the situation. As a political leader he has been a great communicator. Most Indians are incapable to take decisions that has concern for society as a main context, being blessed they are incapacitated to conceptualize themselves as subservient to crucial social restrictions that is indeed matter of life and death. Many see these as affront to their special place in universe. In their grand world every occasion is an occasion presented specially to them to capitalize. It is a society in prisoner’s dilemma with no basic communitarian understanding. Hence it is important that rules are strictly enforced. Again we must thank unfortunate Italians, Spaniards and Iranians. We are incapable to be proactive nor can act with conscience. We need to be shown, and convinced, of the consequences with gory details with repeated requests. Since even this is difficult to get sense of the reality to zombies –who have been isolated from reality for too long, severe action must be initiated against the violators.  

In the midst of de-bullshitting

In the conception of might the state creates grander narrations

Hoarding weapons of mass destructions, accruing more   

There is always bigger threat to protect from

Nation’s security is citizen’s paramount duty.

Sacrifice.

Religions compete to gain its place as guardian angels

Building larger canopies of taller claims

To herd its devotees to safer shore.

Faith.

Market bring slicker side of happiness

That desires multiplications, additions and squaring of details

Consumer is to be fed.

Choices.

A sneeze.

A moment for microorganism

To make the sacrifice laughable

To make the faith absurd

To make the choices meaningless.

Clarity.

             

#WorldPoetryDay

Going viral

This is what going viral really means. When reality strikes all fiction and sensitivities have no use. The foundation of society and human understanding that has isolated itself in abstraction of ego, expressions of parochialism and immediate gains are now forced to face the crumbling conceptions. It’s a reality check that was long overdue as hype, exaggeration and omnipotence was becoming defining parameters. Market and religions contributed to this sense of wellbeing in deviant value system. Vicious type of opportunists evolved in this ecosystem who worked to define the framework of crassness and greed. Knowledge driven inquisitive logical outlook that cared for compassion and empathy was undermined for tapping the primal base of human character, role models were created within these while society coalesced and celebrated these degradations. Crude and opportunist value systems were actively nurtured and presented as success while ruffians controlling religions showered blessing.      

  

  Meanwhile as some humans advanced, the societies evolved, they got more complex and the complexities were sought to be synergized with the emerging realities and to reflect humanitarian concerns. These evolved societies strived to represent the humanity. Globalization was essentially humanitarian expression to bring humanity into one frame before it was hijacked by market opportunists to extend their exploitative and crude frame. Globalized world is now a reality thanks to technological innovation that has reduced distance and made differences redundant. In this evolved world the differences that is appreciated is the one that brings the synergy of uniqueness as human. Democracy was an attempt in this direction before it was scuttled by entrenched feudal forces and reduced to joke but still remains attuned to human reality provided individuals evolves and are able to tap the potential of education and opportunities to work a better self. European Union was such expression in limited scale, and considering the history of this region it was a tremendously appreciable effort. These intentions were also in tune with emerging challenges of globalized world that is essentially a byproduct of technological innovations.    

       

The globalized world presents challenges that needs collaboration at the global level. Climate change, extinction events, pandemics, terrorism so on needs a globalized response. Whatever frame that nurtures divisions, segregations and false narrations of identities will fall by the side when the reality strikes. Vested interests have been nurturing deviant dehumanizing values to control common people and extract opportunities from the misery. The rise of xenophobia has much to do with pushing these opportunistic market values in the garb of globalization thus alienating common people from their unique attributes, local connections and contexts. Dehumanized frustrated people are easy fodder for nationalistic narrations and primal connections. The rise of religious fundamentalism has much to do with nurturing the anachronism of religions as identity by high end manipulators under the garb of moral angst with absolutely no skin in the game. While the common people’s aspiration and insecurities were persistently undermined. These constructed exaggerations on which some clever people were settling their redemption has been jolted in recent times by climate related challenges and increasing desperation among people. These though were sought to be undermined by working on high end angst binary. Wherein people’s insecurities where posited as rising threat to minority (which ofcourse was identified and firmly hinged on vicious religions at the expense of genuine minorities including divergent ideas). Nationalism was sought to be fought with feudal references and norms while market incursions within the comfort of hedonist luxury. Everything was sought to be dealt with control over narration and connection to deep state. Carbon footprint were ignored and climate change sought to be sidelined before they no longer could as things had start to become obvious. Anachronistic nonsenses were packed as benign religions that constantly degraded humanity, giving confidence to dangerous zombies while persistently undermining emerging threats. Science was positioned as binary to religion in this clever conception rather than natural evolution of thinking mind. An inquisitive logical critical mind could easily see through the juvenilities of religion that is striving to gain the space of spiritual inquiry within its stultifying dehumanizing segregatory frame. It was but natural for reality to strike. It strikes through natural disasters. The intensity and frequency of which have increased in recent times. But these too were cunningly factored in and juxtaposed as grand wrath of god and were judiciously isolated from reality (of climate crisis) and placed under religious frame to seek atonement. Punishment and wrath are constant references in religions meant to keep the zombies under check. Ego driven religions have special use of huge natural disasters and calamities, the imagery of deluge and floods, devastating fires so on perversely satisfies the narration of wrath of god onto common people. Afterall only our god can create such grand disasters. Hence he has to be omnipotent, in a deft move followers too share this claim of omnipotence over others as also ego driven insular megalomaniacal insights that put them firmly over common people. That is why threat by microorganism is baffling to their little mind, and is such a humbling experience.  This cannot be really fit into the grand nature of things. It is such an embarrassment to megalomaniacal driven conceptions of religions.  

  

When reality strikes it grabs the balls to squeeze out the hallucination. Exaggerated self-worth and manipulation has no space. Nations are lines on the map while religions are nothing more than sinister virtual games that has no sense of reality. Its strips dictators to bare and force them to share the information. Corona virus wouldn’t have spread if China was democratic and valued human rights same is the case with theocratic megalomaniacs controlling Iran who were in denial mode. USA could have initiated much better response if it were not for market driven manipulation that seeks to obfuscate reality and connection of people to their surroundings.  Human beings are part of nature that is sustained by earth’s system that took millions of years to evolve. In geological terms humans are just blip. We live in wider connection with world in this fragile space. It is quite apt that it needed only a microorganism, a virus, to show us our place in grand scheme of things. It is the great de-bullshitting event of our times. It is humbling.             

stillness

Encountering stillness on an evening walk

The satyagraha bling

The benign narration is being furiously spread for last many decades by castetva forces severely compromising democratic institutions spreading misery while cunningly capitalizing from these. The framework of blessedness was pushed in to keep the herds in place while deceptive rituals –with even minute details of auspicious timing was notified as god’s favored to stampede for amassing blessing, was worked out to emulate to better the fate. Meanwhile benign posers concocted liberal pointers by closely miming the angst need of fattened western fluffs. The castetva deep state henceforth took firm hold of the narration viciously dealing with dissent or attempts at dilution. State machinery worked to nurture people and institutions to back these while western fluffs bleeding to redeem their ill-gotten luxury patronized lowest denominator as wonders of diversity. Casteist racist fellow was spruced up as bearer of morality of greatest known civilization in universe. In the castetva conception of world grandness is contained in grandness of putrid pit. The world has to enter the putrid pit for better understanding. Apart from compelling western liberal pointers the native liberalism of benign all-knowing humble selves conceived liberalsutra of humility wherein secular devi was seductress always in service of nearest monster mullah. Common people and the misery that these spread was least of concern, indeed they were to be kept trapped. They were only fodders, just numbers, to fill in whenever the need arises. They were to be cannibalized at suitable occasion. All the HDI index or any index that works on egalitarian context will exhibit these algorithm of cannibalism. 

          

The deep state is in the process of minor shift as narration control moves from castetva to hindutva. The bleating of castetva is on expected lines. The benign posturing to distinguish themselves from hindutva is rather trite but the attempts are getting so desperate that it display various stages of hypocritical hilarities of mediocres. The other day I was reading views of indian writer (like third rate movies that is churned from this part of the world to keep the herds in putrid pit entertained and assured grandness unmatched in the universe Indian writers too are amazing opportunist mediocres trying to align with deep state to get fed. With western world showing angst for diversity effete indian elite and their litter fervently hope the standard too is compromised so that they can barge in under the garb of diversity. If the rise of China is about authoritarianism and brutal control then the rise of India is about mediocrity and crassness of life). This fellow has started to defecate book at quite an early age and seem quite attuned to the needs of the castetva deep state while trying to demarcate hindutva. It is obvious that he has been acclimatized to liberal pointers hence is being nurtured. His book title even contain obnoxious “Italian brahmin” as if these are normal. This pus is being nurtured to be bigger pus to awe the world while attempting to wrench the narration from hindutva to grandness of benign blessings –the all giving all-knowing caretakers lurking in putrid pit. To showcase this chicanery there is a stampede to control history. One pretender after another is defecating books and columns. It’s a constant endeavor of deep state to present this crude society as sacred offering to humanity.  A society with horrendous past that carries the brutal remnants with care is sought to be presented as holder of humanity’s conscience with mahatmas readied and self-appointed on short notice to oversee the greater goodness of the world while they in all assuredness of charlatans conduct ritual for world peace. Is there anything more sinister than this? 

     

Now this pus posits “our ancestors were far more secure of their identity” to understand what identity is he talking about an obscure medieval play (of what is essentially an overwhelmingly mediocre society with rare sparks) written by some crude feudal is presented. The little pus elaborates “it features a brahmin wooing a dalit woman” (apart from these normalizing of obnoxious references which his limited mind is incapable to comprehend, how common is this premise? Further, considering this society is a caste cannibalized society that is rotten from the foundation. Forget morals these don’t even know to conceive basic definition of society. It’s clear that this fellow is aiming for the highest moral grounds…and there is a coterie working to shoulder him. Through angst connection these arrange international awards to gain credibility). The pus explains “the brahmin says (in the play ofcourse) I drink cow’s milk and worship the cow. You eat the cow so you must be purer than me” and proclaim his grand interpretation of what is essentially a third rate play of lout wanting to f*ck a poor horribly marginalized and exploited woman, he argues to write these “tells you about cultural confidence” (the audacity of the prick to even suggest these). “the ability to laugh at ourselves”…hence “our ancestors were far more secure in their identity”. I don’t know whose ancestors this little scoundrel is talking about.  

History of crude society is waste of time. There is always attempts to work narration to redeem oneself and grandness when the reality is bleak. In a mediocre society with majority intellectually challenged and constantly using education to double their blessing these add to the collective hallucination of special place in universe. This attempts at wrenching history by snarling castetva and hindutva within the narrow range of self-fulfilling narration doesn’t help the case. This was and is indeed a cannibalistic society with worst of references that would put humanity to shame. At the most history need to be about enlightening thoughts and ideas. Instead of grandness humbling references is the need. Take for instance Yuval Harari –well-read international writer, now he looks at history in the entirety of humanity and works to take this understanding to chance the possibilities and the challenges the humanity faces. That makes him a precious historian and his insights are worthy. If there were many writers/historians like him world would be such an exciting place with possibilities.  That also makes Indians a bunch of mediocres scheming in the putrid pit to stampede the highest moral ground and showcase as benign possibly the only meaning in their little lives.

PS:

Today the roads were blocked as this bunch was celebrating a medieval king with revivalist fervor. The noise, the grand bearing as if they themselves were foot soldiers, crude aesthetics and ridiculous dancing, selfies while blatantly stopping the traffic, causing inconvenience…it has everything that defines this society in many ways. Lacking any quaint value system I can only pity them. Seeing many youngsters only confirms the bleakness of this society, and the tragedy is they procreate. Children needs a better understanding of world based on compassion and common legacy of humanity. World has changed significantly in last many decades, it’s conceivable and can be easily conjectured that the best of people who lived few centuries back would have definitely reassessed their thoughts, value systems and action if they had as much awareness of the world as we have now. This reading the history within the contemporary context to create narration of grandness is dangerous. It nurtures value system that is rarely beneficial and can only create misery. It negates the potential of humans.

This picture was taken at festival celebrating gandhi (another protagonist of nuisance narration of grandness, in this case of simplicity. Lots of public money is wasted to work this narration). The dear fellow is shown taking care of leprosy patients, and managed to photographed himself too. And in case you were wondering how this casteist racist would survive the onslaught of squatter (or he himself considering the way he valued impoverished black African) it was clarified that the patient is a fellow with squatter reference. How many times have we come across the picture of Mother Theresa attending the heartrendingly sick where the name of suffering poor is mentioned with surname for posterity? This is gandhian miracle. There is a way the game is played. Charlatans try inbreeding to get the vulgarities going. This is how regrettable gandhi worked on his mahatma (which ofcourse was title granted by squatters to elevate him as equal...since a mere "bania" would diminish their grand valuations of dealing with the world. A "great soul" who could hang out with blessed squatter since is now being confirmed as shared). This then gave the fellow the squatter's itch to be "searcher of truth", the rituals which squatters expertised, clever gandhi sought to extend it by branding through carefully chosen sanskrit references. He was a intellectually challenged eager pawn (you will notice this small time ambitious lawyer had very limited reading habit references, little bit were exaggerated -Tolstoy/Thoreau, to work on civilizationally gifted intellectual calibre that sought universal validation) readied to work on grand narration to present to the world while back home was effectively worked to control the herd. Truth it seems was a weapon. Such is the exaggeration of charlatans who pose as humble souls self appointed as trustees and guardians entitled to negotiate higher forces (which only they have privy to). Satyagraha. The seeker of godforsaken truth. The purity seekers purity of truth in putrefying pit.   

We are not interested in any truth. We are interested in meaning. Meanings are precious.   

   

Attempting benign narrations

There is a constant strive by caste cannibals to showcase as benign overseer. They worked on casteist racist ego driven fellow as paragon of virtue, and since he wasn’t matching squatter tag he was imposed on common people as mahatma.  Castetva have since controlled the narration degrading democratic institutions through nepotism and camaraderie corruption while brutalizing common people into putrid pits. Meanwhile obsessively showcasing as representing an evolved culture with unknowable access to unfathomable. This mystification worked with fattened fluff britishers who beady eyed looked for lowest denominator to patronize so as to atone for their luxury. These entitled positioning has led to amazing nutcases being nurtured by state into public space. Castetva working on entitlements placed it on feudal primal associations, and primitive society had much to offer. With power accrued and consolidated with few (and families) the sycophants attuned to hierarchy and nurtured in puss created their own pecking order. The sycophantic culture created its value system that closely mimicked primitive traditions and worst references which were now mainstreamed to further degrade the society while mounting untold misery on common people. Connecting with sycophancy to powerful and brutal feudal norms with anyone below in pecking order they unleashed deviant value across the power centers. Caste shiv bhakts snuggling to pour milk as they temple hop and snarl liberal pointers. Coterie of manipulators and fixers were fed and nurtured –the very same now working in the perception war against hindutva. These worked to control narration while pliable caste academicians defecated thick books repeating balderdash ad nauseam to somehow overwhelm the truth.      

So as castetva pose against hindutva apart from authenticating caste and other horrendous practices they usurp egalitarian humanistic tradition that is core of any evolving society (before religious structures and power worked on it) they also sought to nurture worst of other anachronistic religions as diversity. This posturing as benign arbitrators is quite persistent. In recent times this seems to be the castetva’s critical positioning against hindutva. Hugging monster mullah at the expense of common people or any ethical moral parameters tops the list, this however is quite old strategy and seems to have lost its gravy since religious fundamentalists are revealed as a threat across the world. If only these were atleast one-billionth civilized. Unlike brutal caste which is being normalized thanks to early inroads into british fluffs monster mullah has become major problem so now the push is for crude ecosystem. So religion is not only pushed as identity but there is nefarious attempts to freeze it as race (even jews cannot be race, the same race has many who do not follow this religion therefore negating this attempt). The benign posturing is now to showcase castetva as inheritors of egalitarian hinduism (an oxymoron since anachronistic religion cannot really be egalitarian, the ideas that emerged few thousand years back in an entirely different context as benchmark for present society is in itself patently unethical and intellectually deficient) as against hindutva which is being relegated as crude. Little scrutiny will show that castetva is only a subset of hindutva, and is indeed extending and facilitating hindutva towards worst references. The present impasse wherein the crude references are being presented has everything to do with how castetva nurtured the democratic institutions towards this bleak eventuality.

There are attempts by well-fed arbitrators to showcase benign castetva through mindset of plenty. The fellow says we need to remove mindset of scarcity. This he points to as our flaw. In the mindset of opulence we are open minded and inviting, he posits, which is what our tradition is. Clearly our benign trustee is aiming for bigger share of gravy in the stampede for highest moral grounds among the entitled benevolent guardians of society. He can keep his opulent mind and move towards congested realities of cities and towns to get some reality check. The problem with these people is that they have no skin in the game whatsoever and defecate to showcase higher morals devoid of any reality scrutiny. That brings us to another protagonist in benevolent castetva posturing. The “infinite truth” BS posturer of otherworldly hindu philosophy and has defecated amazing quantity of books working on the traditions of putrid pit to assure the zombies of their special place in universe. His cunningness is very appropriately targeted by likes of KasturiCannibals and seek to work as egalitarian overseer in the putrefying pit. The fellow is targeting egalitarian values of buddhism in an attempt to appropriate it into castetva fold. Some clever scrotum scratchers have twisted the narration to include Buddha as even an avatara for local consumption as also in a clear attempt to degrade and appropriate into caste sickness. Infinite truth BS vendor is not far behind as he attempts to delineate castetva into egalitarian fold while firmly shutting hindutva. A devious narrative skill that you will see increasingly deployed and nurtured by powerful coterie as they attempt upperhand in their benign arbitrator posturing.

The devious BS vendor working for zombies in putrid pit claims that Buddha was unknown to Indians before a book by britisher! The fellow gets down to the business of appropriating an idea (that is essentially anti-caste and much evolved in context of the time that best of people across the world find quite riveting) “Scholars of the Pali language are trying to differentiate the actual words spoken by the Buddha from later additions by monks, who were mostly from elite Brahmin families”. This elite scrotum scratcher is a well thought of addition to degrade since once anyone joins anti-caste value system to trace the sickness that he shunted is disgusting attempt at appropriation and extending the ideas of entitlement of nutcases. He is persistent in his attempts at denigrating buddhism, his focus now is anti-woman “Gender studies are now pointing out to the essential misogyny and patriarchy of early Buddhism”. Ofcourse these must be true since nobody is valuing buddhism or indeed any system as embodiment of truth. These reflects the context and exigencies of the era. These being pointed out by a fellow who has not yet come out of his putrid pit is what makes it particularly galling. Ofcourse the limited intellect is nurtured by deep state to work the narration to keep the zombies in place.  He writes that “differentiation between Hinduism and Buddhism mattered only in elite circles, between orthodox Brahmins and orthodox Buddhists”. For our man the world is about orthodox scrotum scratchers and others! He seems intellectually incapable that other human being could be interested to know the differentiation. Indeed, in the contemporary context anti-caste differentiation is definitely the reason why it is attracting exploited people (who are quite capable to know these matter unlike the caste cannibal trying to wrench the narration) and there is egalitarian history to it that traces as mainstream humanitarian values that defined this region for centuries. The same that is being undermined by castetva and fed to fatten hindutva. There is a reason why regrettable human and intellectually compromised economist Amartya sen wrote books. The deep state was pushing to consolidate benign narration and showcase the world. Sen was scholarly with well evolved acumen that makes it difficult while “infinite truth BS” is an easy go.  

To end the column the devious fellow masterfully accuses what he himself could be accused of “lazy scholarship, and politics, prefers a static, simplistic and homogenous vision of the past”. The fellow who is seeking to establish castetva narration to showcase benign values in the putrid pit is well adept in inbred chicanery as he snuggle to find sane castetva space of benevolence between “Ambedkarites and neo-Buddhists”. As the manipulator Australian senator says "I am not denying climate change. I keep an open mind". That's the trick of the inane not only talk balderdash but take high moral ground. Control over state machinery, crony capitalism and cannibalistic camaraderie have given lease to these mediocre entitled to showcase their blessing for zombies to emulate. This is effectively the story of this beleaguered primitive society in the last seven decades that constantly seeks worst possible references but still has highest estimate of itself as benign arbitrators of universe that the world is incapable to know.                

          

#JNU violence

Violence in educational institution must be condemned, not because it is located in Delhi therefore camaraderie with high end manipulators hence by default prestigious. It also need to be noted that AMU is known for its regressive ways that is influenced by primitive religion, till recently girl students were not even allowed in library. For this very reason this so called educational institution should have been closed down. The idea of education institutions classified on the basis of religion in itself is questioned. Education has nothing to do with religion, it degrades humanistic values and classifies youngsters while introducing them to anachronistic juvenilities in the garb of faith that closes down their mind and mess with it. A primitive society like India is exceedingly vulnerable. Ofcourse castetva forces have severely degraded the society as they posture benign arbitrators while hindutva is working on revivalist mode to herd the zombies.

Violence in JNU must be condemned but you cannot take side to fit in the narration. It was reported by media that leftist started the fight while right wing responded. Having studied in Kerala in 1990s I am quite aware of vicious nature of leftist student’s organisation (SFI) as also congress (KSU) and right wing (ABVP). SFI is powerful presence, and they are prone to gundaism with political clout. While KSU brings in feudal norms and high end manipulations, ABVP works in with religious acts to create provocation so as to play victim. Campus in kerala during 1980s-90s was quite a violent place, with SFI very much actively involved. So to say that suddenly the world is coming to end with “fascism” is rather ridiculous. Furthermore, having spent some time in JNU and acquainted with strong left wing student politics here I quite well know how it is working. One incident will help elucidate it. So I was having attendance shortage (SIS –international studies, wasn’t much of interest to me except maybe some thinkers) so mostly used to roam around, and spent lots of time in the library and hanged around with few select people while attending talks, seminars and debates. This SFI leader came to know about my predicament. The rules says give reason and repeat (I vaguely remember Prof Chinoy mentioning this to me, well it’s been more than two decades!!) or you are rusticated. But our student leader had other plans, I guess he saw me as potential recruit, not to forget a malayalee comrade. How wonderful. He said like a well-oiled tout in chaste malayalam “we will get it done”, and attempted to hug me which I fiercely resisted. Probably he was working on his easy going nature with north Indian cultural context (Keralites don’t hug, and I absolutely abhor it). So I could be in next semester without any worry or attendance contravening every rule. I dropped the idea since money was a concern and was quite keen on hostel which doesn’t seem to be happening. Balancing money making with academic pursuit wasn't working. JNU is undoubtedly a wonderful place to be in with verdant huge campus right in the core area of Delhi and an excellent library, and if i had got the hostel facility my life would have taken an entirely different turn.     

SFI has a strong presence in JNU which castetva forces see as something of international exotic that has immense potential in presenting oneself as compassionate. Some louts even posed as gandhian leftist and surveyed the scene like a feudal lord immensely happy with the subject and unique blessing that has entitled him these. Those were the good old days, and fattened fluffs in west were much besotted with this high end display of unworldly unity in diversity. Now as hindutva works its way –essentially it is balancing of things into its narration, its student’s wing is quite active. Hence the violence in JNU is a power struggle with outside force quite active as always. Right wing is not ready to back down as it has clout now while left wing is working to maintain its supremacy through increasingly angst narration and uncharacteristic whining. Congress ofcourse is the posturer here seeking opportunity to capitalize and work its narration as castetva saviors –the beholder of unknowable traditions. You cannot take sides without awareness of fact of the matter. If you do then you are being political. Meanwhile violence must be condemned and culprit punished.

Post script: The talk on JNU will not be complete with one hilarious incident. There was this Keralaite student -a thin lanky fellow with long beard, who posed as leftist ideologue, itching for debate all the time. He was always ready with "down with the imperialist" (read USA) line of thought which was interesting sometimes but mostly rant against "liberalization and globalization" (favorite punching bags in mid-1990s if you recall). Now I had forgotten about him then one day few years later I was at American consulate library (at Barakhamba Rd) browsing through some books, and there emerged a familiar face. Clean shaven and tucked in shirt, and it took me a while to place him. He was working at American consulate. And I rubbed it in with much pleasure "What a fall comrade!!" He winked and said he gets paid in dollar! He sponsored the lunch and we parted. Never met him after that.       

Righteous balderdash makes the gangrene septic

As the market works its way up to spoil the references of facts and decency a new form of virulent manipulators have entered the scene with much confidence. These were till recently working in the background as enablers of deceit. They now easily work their way by blurring the lines through market consolidated value system of exaggeration and manipulations. Trump epitomizes this steady rise. And so to resist these there is an attempt by pretentious bunch to pose as benign righteous arbitrators and showcase as saviors. These are the same who have been feeding through the exploitative systems for long and are very much responsible for the impasse that common people find themselves in. Incapable to work out egalitarian values or reference of compassion as also exigencies of time we live in they look for easy atavistic association as a reference to connect. So, as they pose as benign arbitrators blessed with all the necessary attributes to the binary of “bad guys” for people's sake, they work to consolidate worst references as identity that needs protection and this is indeed showcased as basis of human rights.

Religion is quite clearly a gangrene on humanity that is increasingly turning fatal. It is eating into the soul of human and conscience of society. Almost all the problems we face can be directly or indirectly pointed to be arising from context of religions. It is surely making matter worse. It brings in fantastical fiction as an escapism from reality and surroundings. So instead of facing the reality, working on introspection, and using faculties of mind to understand and factor in new ideas and logically established and verified concepts that seeks truth, strive to evolve with all the exciting opportunities, they tend to isolate into some medieval rug sacks and become fatalist or all-knowing confident herds with twisted personal worldviews mediated by religion. They even claim that their religion is more scientific hence better than that of others! Exceptionalism and entitlements over others takes root. This anachronistic juvenile frame is being elevated as choice, and indeed is being recognized as identity and stamped on to hapless people particularly vulnerable children. Nothing is more painful than seeing a religious child. You can see the dying of a civilization in these expressions. It is a tragedy on humanity of colossal scale. Indeed it is sight of death of hope and possibilities. Two hundred thousand years of sapiens evolution is coming to this dead end is truly tragic.  

There is also a sinister attempt to equate these balderdash as race. This incursion must be resisted at every cost. It is becoming increasingly clear that religions are incompatible to modern values and tends to undermine individual liberty and sense of being and therefore suppresses the humanity in each individual. There is a persistent effort by vested interests and sinister bunch with feudal mindsets to keep people segregated in these self-consuming pits. This helps in firm grip and control over fate of common people. While the majority religion in any given region is working with opportunist populism and market pointers to position as savior the minority religion is being sought by those posturing liberal-secular while hinting at egalitarian values and harbinger of human rights. This is being played in most part of the world. And, let’s be clear, at the expense of serious issues and concerns that affects common people. We are at catastrophic crossroads of climate emergency, mass extinction, cataclysmic pollution affecting air, water, soil, and even light. Biodiversity is being degraded, habitats destroyed. There are extreme climatic events that has already arrived. We are losing soil, forests, species…at an alarming rate. And here we are worried about identities based on anachronistic juvenilities. This is quite shocking and hara-kiri moment. Only market greed and deviant religions can create these horrible irresponsible and arrogant humans.  

Sane people who have wide reading habits, are introspective and inquisitive, rigorously work on logical ways and emerging contexts, understand the challenges of contemporary realities and have persistently strengthened critical thinking and argumentative faculties, and are keenly aware of socio-historical and spiritual context of human life, tend to easily see through the balderdash of sinister frames. These are generally referred to as liberal enlightened humans who closely associate with egalitarian and compassionate value systems. Progress of humanity has been very much hinged to them, majority of human beings are just freeloaders working on opportunities and trivialities of the era they live in.  The liberals in the contemporary contexts are not really enlightened souls but opportunistic posturers filling gaps to capture opportunity hence can flip on any side with much ease as and when they see the chance.  The matter is made worse with decreasing attention spans of general populace hooked to social media and easy gratifications, and are easily outraged hinged on visceral reactions. Lack of context or deeper understanding is therefore reflected on people posturing as benign leaders to counter the onslaught of nationalism that is working with regressive revivalism of religion. The reason why Corbyn was defeated falls into these parameters that can be extended to much of West (and also poorer societies too). People are ready to put faith on a person like Boris Johnson, as also are keen to move out of EU has a context (youngster’s concern are job opportunities that EU offers than any politicians so they voted for against brexit -and not Corbyn). The rise of xenophobia has a definite context, and it surely has to do with rising insecurities.

Liberalism and egalitarian values clearly associates with humanism. Human rights as also rights of other species, concern for environment and nature are paramount. 'Liberal left' is another of posturing that needs to be dropped. There are no liberal left, far left or centralist or conservatives…these are categorizing people and issues into preconceived brackets that serves no purpose except dividing and polarizing people, furthering misery while the market media ‘balance’ the debate as the sinister gain. There are issues and challenges that needs to be addressed, and the situation demands how it need to be tackled. Sane people must stop these classifications and dissuade these discussion. Emerging challenges need a new paradigm. Religions are woefully lacking, and indeed are dead weight that humanity really cannot carry.  

It need to be understood very clearly that religion is not an identity and cannot be. It is an affront on being human. The attempt to equate this subjective juvenility to race is not only sinister but denigrates the fight against racism. It was indeed Nazis who connected religion to race and worked on despicable ideas of eugenics. It is amply clear that religions stands against humanistic concerns as they segregate and categorize people while the world gets more and more connected and becomes immediate. The concern for religious minorities (anti-semitism is condemned but that doesn’t exonerate Judaism hence judaophobia is not a problem, these distinctions must be insisted) by those posturing liberal is bringing in regressive primitive frames and value system that is unacceptable and is indeed an affront to humanity. There is a majoritarian reaction which in turn consolidates its own regressive primal connections. What has been gained from the struggle and sacrifices of hundreds of years cannot be allowed to wither away to protect religion that is bringing in misery and surely not solution to any problems.

   

Ideas need to add synergy and openness into society, it must help humans to be aware of themselves and their connection with reality and surrounding that has profound implications. Fragile nature of life and the value system that emerge from this awareness is being persistently undermined by religion –that look for miracles and narrow visions that seek devotees with grander plans and illusions. This cannot work. Communitarian consolidation need only be issue based within the context and challenges that human face, it really cannot be on the basis of juvenile fictions or birth based categorization or associations. This increasingly sickening concern for religion as an identity as also exaggerations herein must stop. Please treat humans as humans, and define society and community on human concern. Common people cannot be held hostage to narrations that hedonist market or sinister religions deem suitable. Religions are threat to humanity and there is no majority or minority about it.  

A song to the ebbing life

There is a quieter place that the faint eyes seek

And let the favorite scenes float

Latch onto one of them

To be taken to a safer synapse above the dying sky  

A world of colors and everyday wonders

Catch the whiff of fading cirrus etchings

Sing with the lyrics of the passing skein

Religions are gangrene on humanity

This beleaguered society has been in the stranglehold of mythmakers, and when they are scrotum scratchers arising from the depth of immoralities of sanctum then you need to shudder. These are the most vicious forms of humans adept in depravities that will put humanity to shame but in their cunning ways manage to even morph these into high morals. If need be they can even convince cannibalism as benign expression of human right so that a vegan too will look forward to consume his neighbor. They make a casteist racist obnoxious patriarch a mahatma, sufficiently impress fattened fluffs in west with their repository of seduction techniques, including the unfailing large pupil lip quivering act that beady eyed fattened fluffs in west are particularly susceptible to. Thus casteist racist is an apostle of peace while a primitive society epitomizes diversity in unity meanwhile caste degradation –that is strictly controlled and worked through segregatory patriarchy, becomes foundation for community. The mythmakers have patched up a shitpot and presented to the world as a wonder. Meanwhile with the control of state machinery went about normalizing these at the expense of common people. Caste atrocities and all kind of crimes that pupate out of these depraved value system were factored in as law and order issue, which ofcourse was kept tardy while judiciary moped the rest.

With castetva losing the power suddenly India seems to be spiraling into violence has the context. This society was never nonviolent, indeed the so called apostle himself was depraved manipulator, it’s a brutal society and the protagonists posturing saviors, trustees and liberal secular are very much the perpetrators. Fattened fluffs in west vulnerable in their colonial angst have already lowered even the lowest denominator of expectation hence casteist easily breeze in as human right crusaders, angst ridden souls and benign colleagues. Now, another aspect of the narration here is to vitiate the environment to take the attention from you –the primitive hometruth, so that you remain in benign frame. This also helps in hiding the mediocrities, you can always hide lack of competence by working up angst or else degrade others. Casteist therefore work quite well in degraded ecosystem. They are therefore in the forefront to make the monster mullah comfortable since they can only dehumanize people. Dehumanizing, segregating and misery creating frames are their specific concern hence religion is undoubtedly an identity that needs to protected at whatever cost, indeed they look for worst reference within these anachronistic juvenilities too. They show characteristic lack of concern for common people meanwhile adept in camaraderie and nepotistic associations.

Not surprisingly the casteist Indians found racist colonials as their natural allies, there was so much in common that they were enamored, hence worked as lawyer negotiators while posing as freedom fighters. Lacking any empathy or concern they agreed on division of societies into countries on the basis of religion. Castetva now blames Hindutva, but the fact is it was Castetva who got the power and ruled for 70years, not Hindutva. As always projecting themselves as reluctantly primitive, reluctantly accepting power for the sake of people, is part of the con act. Always reluctant benign overseer, very humbly accepting the blessing. What can poor souls do but to accept the fate of blessed to rule the miserable? And the zombie populace is mesmerized. Now ofcourse Castetva is beaten in its own game. Thus the final trump card: the muslims, not the common muslims but the worst type who are kept fed with all primitiveness intact, indeed celebrated. Monster mullah as always take the attention from casteist cannibals –who pose as humanitarian facilitators for highest values that humanity could conceive. Monster mullah have always been hunted, trapped and fed by caste cannibals, it is called secular game of high stakes and it was always at the expense of common people who were pushed into further despair. Meanwhile to showcase modernity hedonist feudal muslims were also cultivated who authenticated castetva’s depravities with much charm. Hedonist muslims posturing as public intellectuals were worst as they authenticated caste, indeed in many cases viscously so, charming the castetva to no end as they share gourmet food in high end eateries in Europe with fattened fluffs joining in for multicultural amusement lessons.

Without having any understanding of egalitarian values, nor any connection with empathetic context nor any caliber Castetva conceived modern references as rituals. Secularism therefore was the new deity that demanded hierarchy of rituals. The goddess need to be appeased and kept hidden from the scrutiny of common people. Mystification was key to power and was always a control mechanism. People have to be kept segregated and trapped in their own misery, this was a constant reference that was affirmed on every occasion. This then was the modernizing contexts into which Indians were being negotiated. It is not surprising that these depravities have infected every possible dealings in this society, creating a fractious suspicion driven fatalistic society that constantly drivels to worst possibilities. High sense of entitlement also assumed proprietary right over common people and gave unique capacity to assume as patronizing arbitrators who have been assigned to take care of muslims. Secularism god needs sacrifice and common people were always in good supply –who were sufficiently drummed in to see all the unfolding of their miserable life as fate. Ofcourse hindutva has no such niceties, being rooted to indian reality than castetva (which is more of image building exercise for west, as also to position themselves) they know their strengths, and it is an obvious outcome of castetva’s devious ways. Cunning gandhi saw himself as blessing on common people, very much orchestrated by conniving castetva and wily colonizers, hence sought to represent them. Castetva was positioning to represent –with a resolute aim to control and capture power, those whom they did not even considered humans while clinging to inhuman framework! Gandhi even had the audacity to refer some humans as ‘children of god’. This entitled positioning and depraved value system was detrimental to the foundation of egalitarian society. There is a reason why gandhi is an essential lynchpin between castetva and hindutva, that makes the shift so easy. This also the reason why hindutva will very likely move towards worst reference of hinduism.

Guhas day out: there is palpable excitement among castetva forces, who having lost power were scheming too long without much success. So recent deterioration of situation, had them excitedly sniffing. More deaths will help pose their angst branding. It must be added here that use of provocative language by hindutva (essentially by Home Minister) vitiated the issue that could have been handled better. The same things, and worst, were achieved by castetva with semantics, compelling turn of sentences and blessed humbleness. Hindutva urgently needs lessons on semantics cleverness. Also, they need to cultivate and understand the leverage points of international media (that castetva have effectively and nepotistically cultivated in the last many decades). It need be noted that prominent international media reported the violence in Assam as protest against “anti-muslim act” –which surely it wasn’t, setting the tone for present situation. The footprint of castetva manipulation is very much obvious.        

Pretentious Guha, the poster boy of castetva’s gandhian hedonism thriving branch, was very much in attendance. He is an ace mythmaker who while working on gandhi as a superman –who visited earth on special request, also creates legends out of amazingly ordinary in dumb game called cricket. Lacking any skills the mediocre protagonists in this stupid game were elevated as stunning sportsmen through his raconteur skills. Anecdotes replaced any sporting skills to make these pathetic endearing. Camaraderie always sought mediocrities of cricket to bind, and guha was right up there. When I first saw I was mesmerized by TV and the whole idea of watching something live (for my teen mind this surely was terrific), and they used cricket to trap common people. Though Indian cricketers were all always legends what surprised me was that they were lowly compared to even small collection of islands westindies, and were themselves genuinely surprised to win ‘world cup’ –which still is a reference for followers of this dumb game. Guha’s version of history closely mimes what castetva forces worked for Indians, and this they viciously want to protect. Hindutva version of history seek to demolish this carefully constructed version. It’s going to be another addition to the saga for common people.

There is no reason to trust pretentious guha, who claims to be atheist while carrying a casteist reference meanwhile keeping keen eye and marveling on temple structures while driving his car. It is a set up that is optimally attuned for sucking. They know which keys to press to maximize, and are keenly aware of inside of the game and positioning herein. What took me years to understand for them these are part of family legacy and shared as camaraderie pointers. Valson Thumpu, an insider, has unique insight into the posturers. One human right posturer even wrote recently that all refugees from everywhere must be invited to India, it is our culture our tradition of vaasudeva kutubukam, he proposes without any irony. These people who haven’t been able to come out of their putrid caste pit, these very people who will not allow even an acquaintent to enter their home (forget strangers) nor share their vehicle in heavy crowd or offer lift or stop for stranded stranger in rain are taking highest moral grounds as branding exercise as benign trustees of great civilization that world has not understood yet, indeed may not have blessing to understand. For the record, I was kind of shocked that when I, a complete stranger, an absolute nobody, visited Valson Thumpu some twenty years back and was asked to share breakfast with them. This will never happen with castetva posturers nor the “beleaguered minority” –the hedonists feudal muslims specially fed to authenticate castetva. Indeed they will make every effort to degrade you, in the process work to showcase themselves as benign. Indeed it is very likely that for the likes of guha this is probably one of the few occasions in their life that they have come in touch with common people on the streets (and you can take that literally and metaphorically). This stampede to high moral grounds is all about branding. 

  

The recent incidents happening around the country has clear hand of castetva, and is being orchestrated. Ofcourse hindutva will do its work to consolidate its own base. It’s very unlikely that they will be reaching for egalitarian references. Atleast they could work on the semantics, be less provocative and remove the controversial references. Just a mention of "prosecuted minorities from neighboring countries" was appropriate rather than stating religion but then politicians are incorrigible they will seek any opportunity to capitalize. Sickening.         

      

A for Ayodhya, T for Temple

 Let this be clarified at the outset that I strongly hold the view that religions are anachronistic nonsenses that are quite effortlessly being used by charlatans to control herd populace (who are trapped in their own differing scales of misery and misfortune). In recent times the exciting and unprecedented possibilities of technological as also socio-political developments have been substantially and seriously undermined by muck arising from religious contexts. Religions have become source of dehumanization as it is disconnecting people from reality. Even though a century or two back religions had some relevance to grapple the increasingly unknown reality but this very source is now attempting to deny the reality that we have understood, instead of enlightening people of the possibilities it is fictionalizing what is apparent, and this, in the process, is weakening the critical faculties of human. This is where the fake news, rumors, prejudices etc. start to have a free run and society, already cynical with market manipulations and exaggerations, finds itself dealing with unsurmountable problems. There is denial, there is escapism and then there are manipulations by charlatans. The structure of religions have ossified and are reduced to source of segregation and exploitation. They seem woefully incapable to factor in new understandings and realities. Individuals have need to find spiritual solace but they have to be intelligent enough to understand where they are being manipulated, where their individuality is being trampled and uniqueness destroyed. They need to protect their inquisitive questioning selves and should resist any attempt to reduce their reality. They must examine their life at every step and shouldn’t leave it to others. They may have direct connection to their faith but need to use their critical faculties on matter where there is a medium that is seeking to work as guide, that is occupied by manipulators who seek devotees as numbers to work their clout. They may find solace in religious texts but need to be constantly aware of the contexts and work on benign interpretations. They must understand change is for good and that it doesn’t in any way a threat to faith and infact is an exciting addition, and that the reality we are understanding through inquiry is part of revelation of unknown forces. One can indeed posit it as god. One need to creatively deal with the reality. For this to happen there must be independence of thinking. So in the contemporary world of possibilities when we you see overzealous religious youths it is always tragic for the society. It is a limitation for a human and a restriction on humanity.

Religious structures too have become bigger and vicious in its competition and posturing. The more unenlightened and primitive the society the worse it becomes. It rarely has the aesthetic connections that traces to its spiritual beginnings and benign intents. They are another extension of acquisitive culture and predatory mindset. The world doesn’t really need any more religious structures. It needs more space for silence, a place to commune with oneself and nature. The world needs more open spaces and gardens, and increasing connection and awareness of biodiversity. It’s about time that in the name of faith, hard earned and immensely valued, democratic systems are not allowed to be ransacked. Lots of damage has been done in recent times. Exciting technologies are only fueling the baser selves.

The tragedy of Ayodhya is part of this nonsense that is being served on tribulations of common people. 'Lord Ram' is significant presence for people in north India (it has pan India impact and is part of daily life in north India). When you meet someone in village the common salutation is ‘ram ram bhaiya’ when they take dead body for cremation they pray ‘ram naam satya hai’ all through the journey. These are essential part of life in north India and reference of Ram is indelible part of popular culture and tradition. 'Lord Ram' is a significant part of their faith and reality of life in this region, so is the stories related to him as avatar that is known to every Hindu which adds to the aura. What is also known to every Hindu is that Ram was born in Ayodhya, and this is an ancient 'knowledge'. These may not pass any factual scrutiny but what is true to most is that Ram was born in Ayodhya as an ancient belief. Therefore it can easily be logically be conjectured that there must have been a big temple in Ayodhya dedicated to lord ram. And it very likely that these were destroyed by Muslim invaders. And that there was nothing wrong in these acts of destruction since these were norms of the time (as also Hindus too have destroyed many Buddhist sites, so too one sect against another, it’s always byproduct of power) as also there was always intention to loot as temples were known to be endowed with riches hence easy target. Most importantly these were squatter occupied caste nurturing sites that spread the worst forms of infection into society and were centers emanating degrading value system. So the destruction temples were not entirely unwelcomed by common people.

But Ayodhya need to be seen in a different perspective since it is connected to the daily life of millions of common people and lack of temple in what is considered as the most sacred site was a glaring absence. This is an unbelievably significant emotive issue. The manipulative cunning politicians realize it. If Castetva forces had any empathetic context they would have rectified it at the onset when India got independence, it was easiest thing to do without causing any harm. But they used this emotive issue as a festering opportunity to showcase their benign self to the world (specifically West, from where they desperately seek nourishment to pose as liberals). They exhibited their unique entitlement of proprietorship over misery ridden common hindus while they patronized beleaguered muslims with fanfare called secularism they acquired to hide their primitive selves. In the meanwhile to get the enmity thriving they acted to keep the emotive issue burning and incrementally allowed it to deteriorate, to fuel the situation into crisis and went about milking it. These are the most dangerous people, they pose as benign "trustees" but cannibalize. The arrogance and special place in universe assured them that they could control it while playing liberal secular to the world. What they did not factor was Hindutva snatching the control. Indeed Castetva worked to help Hindutva to easily snowball it and gain credibility. Hindutva is the reality while Castetva is fake and devious. Whether Hindutva is able to work on the egalitarian aspects of Hinduism is the challenge. It is an uphill task since Castetva have seriously degraded the society, as also they will seek to vitiate to gain control (a study of sabarimala issue will help to understand this critical matter). So instead of finding the egalitarian references things will get reactive as Castetva will mimic soft Hindutva in an existential fight to not get sucked by it. Castetva is a subset of Hindutva, desperately posturing liberal secular will not help stop the breach. The fake will have to find their true self. Power and greed will make it easy homecoming. Castetva holds no solution, and are indeed part of the problem. It’s better for sane people to shift their attention to Hindutva and help it work to steer towards egalitarian value systems. Difficult since at the end of the day religion too is problematic.     

It was therefore but natural for temple to be at Ayodhya, it was already an emotive issue connected to millions of common hindus of this region much vitiated by cunning politicians. Anything else would have had serious ramifications. It’s not really about majoritarianism or unleashing of fascism (it's interesting castetva taking up fascism!) as is being posited by cunning posing as liberal secular. SC has dealt the matter competently and was much nuanced in its dealings. Ideally a garden would have been much better option but in the context of the heightened emotions, also understanding how much deeply it is connected to narration of faith for common Hindus in the region, it is surely sacrilegious. Mosque issue here is not connected to common Muslims and is being exaggerated by cunning section posing high morals at the expense of common people. They really want common muslims to become extreme, and yes some leaders will seek to gain but this will be against the interest of common people –whom they don’t much care when the gravy is somewhere else. These are fuelled by dangerous forces who conveniently ignore the ground reality and cataclysmic undercurrents for personal gain. Religious structures have lived their life but a temple in Ayodhya for Ram brings an end to centuries long contentious matter. It’s time to move forward.