Tuesday, August 04, 2015

IUCN, WWF, CITES must answer

"Trophy hunting is a form of wildlife use that, when well-managed, may assist in furthering conservation objectives" (IUCN)


My respect for WWF is substantially diminished over the years, now the intent of CITES, as was elucidated by one of its spokesperson, has appalled me in no small measure. As one was trying to come in terms with serious ethical breaches and moral expediencies comes the revelation of IUCN. Are these people for conservation or is conservation a ruse for furthering themselves and their ways, animals as a convenient alibi to spread oneself. Animals cannot speak so you can be the spokesperson and manipulate (reminds me of cunning Indian elite who with effortless feudal ease seek to represent common people and rub it in through ever purifying moral matrix). 
It is becoming quite clear that the wildlife related conservation issues are still run by erstwhile hunters and colonisers. The kind of literature on hunting by colonisers will leave you baffled, the depravity of it beyond shock. Indeed if you visit Bharatpur bird sanctuary you will see a placard on the number of birds killed in one go, it crosses thousands. What kind of sick people will do these? These hunting zones were protected as they wanted the numbers to increase so that they can kill for their perverse pleasure. These regions later acquired the status of wildlife sanctuaries, so conservation wasn’t the early concern. During these massacres of animals for pleasure common people’s knowledge were used for tracking, while Indian elite were enthusiastic participants of massacre creating their own records to match the masters. In the weekends they cemented further as they fawned over master’s gentlemanly attributes through cricket (like squatter’s temples cricket was also quite successfully pushed through the throats of common people, with immense success and relish. Cursory study will show how mediocrity thrived as it sucked on), they also got essential lessons on modernity that they easily blended into feudal norms and sickening traditions.

It is in this context I find the ease to analyse WWF, CITES, IUCN so on (I must again express my gratefulness to Indian elite and their depraved ways). Clearly the erstwhile hunters and decadent colonisers have occupied responsible positions in the wildlife conservation related organisations. They might have morphed themselves successfully as conservators but their intent will show in the crucial situations. ‘Trophy hunting’ is such an occasion where they open up as practical souls with higher intent in mind.  The kind of conservation strategy that they pursue quite clearly carries the legacy of brutes and colonisers. Selective killing maybe used as a last resort to balance or to weed out, in rare instances, but trophy hunting is a different matter. It seeks to encourage sick minds and their debauched ways, it is awfully disturbing. Even the monetary gains and ‘economic incentives’, that seeks to exploit the poverty in an exceedingly classist framework, doesn’t stand scrutiny. A study shows that 70.4 percent of Americans would pay to view lions on an African safari, while only 6.6 percent would pay to hunt them.

The people who are holding responsible positions in WWF, IUCN, CITES etc. must be scrutinised closely, the erstwhile scums seems to have morphed as conservators. Ironically people who are connected to forest and its ways generally tend to be sustainable in the practice and compassionate in their outlook. They rarely kill for fun, sick thrills nor will support depraved minds, their poverty (which ofcourse is the result of skewed nature of socio-economic system, than any claim to competence. Donald trump is a sterling example) is being exploited for furthering one’s debauched ways.
The picture herein is that Donald trump’s son. A CNN newsreader, an Afro-American trying to balance the discussion, was saying in defence of Trump “...but his children are normal and not in wrong ways”. Being normal is such a big deal, even in this limited ethical space look what is there to see. Sickening.